Claims and Payments Grundy Insurance Claims: 888-647-8639 Payments: 866-338-4006 Hagerty InsuranceClaims: 888-220-9565 Payments: 800-762-2628 Liberty MutualClaims: 800-332-3226 Payments: 800-332-3226 Liberty Mutual CommercialClaims: 888-292-0249 Payments: 866-290-2920 Main Street America InsuranceClaims: 877-425-2467 Payments: 800-258-5310 Nationwide InsuranceClaims: 800-421-3535 Payments: 800-543-3747 Philadelphia Insurance Claims: 800-765-9749 Payments: 877-438-7459 ProgressiveClaims 800-776-4737 Payments 800-888-7764 Travelers InsuranceClaims: 800-252-4633 Payments: 877-878-2468